From the Left and the Right we are constantly bombarded by those who wish to either wish to save us or control us by choosing their moral code by which we must live. Not ours, theirs.
Legislating Morality
He was as great as a man can be without morality. ~ Alexis de Tocqueville
It is a truism that almost any sect, cult, or religion will legislate its creed into law if it acquires the political power to do so, and will follow it by suppressing opposition, subverting all education to seize early the minds of the young, and by killing, locking up, or driving underground all heretics. ~ Robert A. Heinlein
There ought to be a law. We need to prevent that, if only that was against the law.
How often have you heard someone utter those inane sentences? Usually it is someone who has a desire to “do good” or have a strong desire to control society. If one thinks about the previous statement, both parties don’t have much difference between them. And coercion is a fine means of achieving the end results.
What is the goal to which both groups aspire? One side claims to save your soul; the other to control your mind and body. The first believes that Moses came down from the Mount with a bunch of tablets, dropped and broke all but one that contained the Ten Commandments. The other side thinks they are nothing more than the Ten Suggestions; they borrow from them when needed and discard the unwanted. No matter how we mix their attempts, they desire to constrain your ‘Free Will’, your moral choices, that would be your ethical codes and supplant yours with theirs.
The two following Federal laws, each, supplanted your “Free Will”, one by a puritanical Victorian Postal Inspector lobbying Congress and the other a group of teetotalers who didn’t like you drinking.
Examination of two such Federal laws should provide some insight as to the efficacy of such legislation. First is the Comstock Law of 1873, which made abortion unlawful. It certainly did not prevent abortions. In October 1919, Congress passed the Volstead Act, better known as the Prohibition law urged by the Women’s Christian Temperance Union and other anti alcohol groups. Any student of history knows this brought on the largest bootlegging and moonshining violations of the law. Crime became rampant and drinking didn’t cease. One small fact unknown to most is that Congress exempts itself from all laws they pass. Party hearty long and on.
Extending this legislating of morality, how is the war on drugs doing, teen smoking, teen drinking, DUI, domestic abuse, rape, child abuse, driving while texting, seat belt use, speeding and the beat goes on. What about the great Leftist bugbear: Guns. Currently between Federal, State and Local ordinances, there are over 20,350 laws constraining firearm use on the books. Many actually contravene the Second Amendment. Those were passed knowing full well the impossibility of challenging them due to the cost; it would take a serious occurrence to move a suit up to SCOTUS.
Most of the aforementioned laws on the books are not seriously enforced such as teen smoking, littering, loitering, seat belt use, truancy, texting while driving, cell phone while driving and more. If strictly enforced, the courts would be clogged. These laws are on the books for harassment purposes, to add charges or place charges on persons as desired.
Can we successfully codify morality? Certainly the words can be placed is a legal context so that offending such codes may be punished. The question still remains, “Can we put morality into a law that stops persons from violating said laws?”
If one wants the opposite of morality in an acronym PEWSLAG will do.
PEWSLAG ~ the seven Deadly Sins:
- Pride: Inordinate opinion of one’s own value
- Envy: Covetousness for others goods or fortunes
- Wrath: Fierce anger, ire
- Sloth: Lazy indolent habits
- Lust: Illicit cravings for others property or carnal pursuits
- Adultery: Voluntary violation of bonding vows
- Greed: Rapacious desire of worldly goods and possessions
If we don’t violate these seven, we have a basis for walking a moral path; following the Ten Suggestions would complete the trek. For those who need stronger guidance, we do have laws to punish the miscreants. Again, this is after the fact. Do we want weak punishment or harsh sentences? Incarceration keeps the individual out of circulation while educating them in how to avoid capture in the future. Death sentences prevent recidivism. The latter definitely works; the former is open to debate.
What we wish to know is do these laws work? For that answer one only has to look to Chicago with that cities plethora of restrictive gun ordinances. The unlawful use has more than two murder a day by thugs offing each other but worse innocent bystanders on the street and in their homes. Their answer to this carnage has been to pass more restrictive laws and an amoral society.
This change started back in the 1930’s with the Social policies of the FDR Administration and the Democrat controlled Congress. Very slowly American changed. Thirty years later, the LBJ “Great Society” finished the nuclear family for 24% of America. With that went the guidance, the inculcation of morality into the children. A child is born feral, that is a survival trait. Civilizing them is necessary for an orderly society. By tearing apart the family, pulling out the male authority, that portion of the process is curtailed. Instead a poorly formed moral code in a peer group ‘teaches’ a moral code tat “feels good” to that pack; it suits what passes for “OK” for the day.
No person can rise above the feral level without a moral code that maintains a civilized society; if one wishes to live in a constant state of siege, where opening the front door means sallying forth on to a Lord of the Flies existence, then we need to change back to the concept of the nuclear family to start and then bring back the extended family as far as possible. There was always someone watching, including the neighbors, over the kids and their activities. No one got away with any antisocial behavior for any parent would put a stop to such activities quickly.
Not so today. Any parent that did that would be sued if not arrested. And we’re paying for it with the disintegration of families and neighborhoods.
Filed under: Peccable reflections | Tagged: Communists, History, Mobius strip of stupidty, Politically Correct, Pusillanimity, Reality, Social Democrats, State Owned Media, The Liberal Plantation | Leave a comment »